Q&A :: When You Have Feelings for a Guy But He Doesn’t Know You Exist

About once a week I write for my single friends based on my own experiences of life as a single woman. Today’s post comes from an email I received recently. She writes:

“I would like to see an article that addresses/opens conversation about what to do when you have feelings for someone (but are not dating and have no idea if he is interested in you). I have a history/struggle with developing feelings for a guy and thus far in my track record nothing ever comes out of it.”
Photo Credit: Creative Commons

Was this the story of my life, or what? I completely understand this reader’s dilemma. Sometimes no matter how hard you try to stop thinking about this man who you are sure is perfect and your dream-come-true, your mind takes you to the place of no return.

If only he would notice you, right?

It may be a stranger who you pass on the way to class or to get coffee at the office. It may be a guy “friend” in your same circle. Maybe he’s even the brother of one of your girlfriends. Regardless you are convinced that if only he would notice you the two of you would click perfectly, and the rest would be history.

For the most part these “mental crushes” are very typical of young (and even older) women. However, from my experience, they can get out of control quickly and become an ugly word – an obsession.

Now, I don’t mean to imply obsession like we hear about on TV or see in the media. I don’t mean some crazy type of obsession, even though these types, too, begin in the mind. I’m talking about subtle obsessions that no one even knows about. The kind that make it hard to concentrate, change your interests, and certainly affect your relationship with God.

Anything we do over and over again with even a tinge of anxiety can become an obsession. In this case what we’re doing over and over again is thinking – about him.

The Bible tells us to “Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it” (Proverbs 4:23).

Our minds are very powerful. Everything that comes out of our hearts starts in our minds. In our minds we can create any reality that we want and actually start believing that it’s true. I think this is Satan’s most used and successful weapon.

We begin thinking about a man, going where we know he’ll be, trying to ‘accidentally’ run into him, and talking about him to all of our friends. This begins to affect our ability to be content, wise, and rational, and it conjures up in our minds a false reality.

“Well, he said, ‘I’ll see you tomorrow’. If he didn’t like me he wouldn’t have said anything at all”, or “He asked me what I’m doing for Christmas, so he must care about me”, or “He smiled at me when I passed him in the hall today, so maybe he was trying to get my attention”.

We analyze every word, every facial expression, every mannerism, and then think they mean something in our favor.

So what do we do about these mental crushes?

1. Put distance between you and the guy. I know this is not always possible, especially if you’re in a work situation or a situation you can’t control, but when you can control it, distance yourself from the crush. Don’t purposely find a seat on the row behind him or walk the same path you know he walks. For me, the more I was around the person, and the more I tried to manipulate the situation, the bigger my crush and the less peace I felt. And just as a side note, I am one of those people who firmly believes that adult men and women cannot be friends. If you are telling yourself that you are “just friends”, then I urge you to really reevaluate your motives.

2. Pray with pure intentions. Believe it or not, even our prayers can be tainted by the enemy’s ugly untruths. Pray that God honestly remove this crush from you. Don’t pray with the secret intention that He works it out and y’all end up together. Completely surrender it to Him knowing that because the guy has not asked you out, then God’s answer is obviously “no”. Could that change? Of course, but you have no evidence of that until something happens. And remember, you cannot manipulate God’s plan. Just let go of it completely.

3. Pray by asking, “God, what am I using this crush to replace in my life?” Obsessions in our minds feed us in some way. Otherwise, we wouldn’t keep coming back to them. Ask God to show you what it is that you are trying to get from this crush that you are not getting in your life and your relationship with Him. He may miraculously take the crush from you, but more often than not He is going to use it to teach you something about your relationship with Him. Is there something that you want to teach me? Something in my relationship with you? Something in my past? What do you want me to learn about you in this situation? How can I grow closer to you?

We think that these little mental crushes – or obsessions – magically disappear once we get married. But friends, I am here to tell you that they do not always. Just because you are married does not mean that you will automatically be immune from thoughts about other men. Now is the time to practice guarding our hearts by taking the advice in 1 Corinthians 10:5: “We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ.”

 How do you deal with mental crushes? What would you add to this list? If you’re married, what wisdom do you have to share today? Please join us in the comments! 

Do you have a question about dating, relationships, or singleness? I would love to answer it here in another post! Email me at brenda{at}triplebraidedlife{dot}com!

Comments

6 responses to “Q&A :: When You Have Feelings for a Guy But He Doesn’t Know You Exist”

  1. Stephanie Avatar
    Stephanie

    Love this post! I recently realized I had a “mental crush” for the first time in maybe 6 or 7 years. It was a really confusing time. Growing up I always had girl friends so at the age of 23 when I started attending a young adults program, figuring out what friendship with a guy looks like was a real lesson…it definitely drew me closer to God. My prayer was to help me love them like brothers, as the bible calls us to do. Which I found easy for all but one guy. Something about his love for God made my heart flutter lol. So it was a rough time with a lot of prayer and seeking God. It kind of funny because I went through everything you wrote about. Not seating next to him, not going place just because he was there etc …anyways, like I said this is a great post and I know it will help a lot of girls.

    1. Brenda Avatar

      Thank you, Stephanie! I am so happy it was helpful, and I’m so glad you commented! I never had guy friends growing up either, so that might why is was hard for me to have guy friends as an adult. It just never worked for me. And observing others I really don’t think it ever works for them either. You brought up an excellent point that mental crushes make it hard for you to see a man as a brother in Christ. We as women are so relationship oriented that this whole thing is so hard for us. Thank you for your comments!! 🙂 

  2. Melissa Butler Avatar
    Melissa Butler

    This post is right on time for me.  I am single and I have a work crush for a while now.  When it first started I embarassed myself to no end.  He has always made it clear he isn’t going there and he does it in a way I can respect.  We are “just friends” and go to the movies or dinner outside of work, but you are right those friendship lines are very hard when one person (me) secretly wishes it was more.  God had convicted me about this and I had gotten better about it, but I can feel myself drifting back to that place.

    I hate to agree with your comment that guys and girls can’t be friends, b/c I really wish it wasn’t the case.  I believe the main reason is b/c sharing takes place between friends and that creates a bond, which isn’t right in a male/female friendship.  Brenda – can you share more of your thoughts on that?

    It is especially hard when you are in close proximity to a great guy and any good relationship should begin as friends.  I also believe that God gives men the discernment to know who to seek since they are the one charged with the finding. 

    He who finds a wife finds a good thing And obtains favor from the LORD. 
    Proverbs 18:22

     

    1. Brenda Avatar

      Melissa, thank you for your honest comments! Most of us have been in the exact place you are. It is a really hard call and hard situation. I will write a post soon about my opinions about guys and girls being friends. I have a lot to say about that topic! 🙂 My initial thoughts are, yes, good relationships are good friendships too and start out that way, but if you use a dating then courtship “model of dating” – I hate that term “model” but don’t know what else to call it – then I think the dating season is when the friendship is built (and continues to be built) but both of you are pursuing a friendship with the same purpose or intention which is to pursue courtship and then possibly engagement. It gets complicated when both people aren’t on the same page as to why your “hanging out”. 🙂 

  3. Victoria Avatar
    Victoria

    I have a crush and my friend tells me he lights up and smiles alot when they talk about me around him. But today we were in gym and my friend was telling me to wait outside she was going to get him and when she came back she told me he ran into the locker room when she tried to get him. Please help.. I really like him and I dont understand if he likes me or not

    1. Brenda @TripleBraided Avatar

      Victoria, my initial response is to not chase boys! 🙂 And I say that with love! Guys will pursue you if you let them. I used to play games and get friends to get his attention for me, etc., but it doesn’t work out very well. It’s not your job to decide if he likes you or not. Just be yourself when he’s around and see if he asks you out, etc. And if he never asks you out or shows you further interest, then realize that you would not appreciate him when you’re in a relationship and he can’t take the role of a man, so it’s for the best. I hope this is helpful!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.